The most unlikely subject matter for a show on Broadway proves exactly why it belongs there
For a Broadway audience, playwright Bruce Norris could have weighted the theatrical playing field slightly more. He could have written a play about a recovery house for MAGA Republicans. Instead, he has written a play about child sex offenders. Norris’ play “Downstate” opened Sunday at Booth Theatre after productions at Off Broadway’s Playwrights Horizons, Chicago’s Steppenwolf and London’s National Theatre.
“Downstate” takes place in a church-run residence for sex offenders who live in a house that is continually being vandalized. Those concerned (and often violent) neighbors have also joined forces to expand the safety-zone perimeter around a local school that will have the effect of restricting even further the mobility, not to mention the grocery-shopping habits, of these four men convicted of sex crimes against minors. The warning about the new law comes courtesy of Ivy (Liza Colon-Zayas), a case worker who shows little sympathy for her charges. She’s just one woman against four men, but Ivy has the law on her side and wears it like an AR-45 bulletproof body armor.
Norris also uses Ivy’s status in the legal system to toy with our sympathies. As precise as a metronome, this playwright’s exposition drops one fact after another regarding just how little freedom these men retain after serving considerable prison sentences. No cellphones, no internet access, no credit cards, no female visitors, no alcohol — the list is itemized, each restriction methodically spaced and delivered throughout the two hours and 30 minutes of this two-act play. Somewhere in the second act, the police monitor wrapped around their ankles becomes…
